Why Tree Topping is Detrimental: Insights from Apex Tree Service

‍

In the world of tree care, there are practices that are universally recognized as harmful by arborists, and tree topping is at the top of that list. At Apex Tree Service, we often encounter homeowners asking about topping their trees, believing it's a way to control growth or reduce size. However, we're here to explain why this practice is not only frowned upon but actively avoided by professionals.

What is Tree Topping?

Tree topping involves cutting back large, often mature branches to stubs or to lateral branches not large enough to assume the terminal role. This drastic pruning method is sometimes used to reduce the height or spread of a tree quickly, but at what cost?

The Dangers of Tree Topping:

1. Stress and Decay:

- Topping removes a significant portion of the tree's foliage, which is crucial for photosynthesis. This leads to a state of shock for the tree, causing it to produce a burst of new growth from the cut areas. These new shoots are weak and more susceptible to disease and pests, increasing decay.

2. Structural Instability:

- The rapid, excessive growth from topping forms branches with poor attachment strength, making them prone to breaking, especially under the weight of new growth or during storms. This creates a safety hazard.

3. Increased Maintenance:
- Contrary to the initial goal of reducing work, topping increases the need for future care. The tree requires more frequent pruning to manage the weak, fast-growing branches, leading to higher maintenance costs over time.

4. Energy Waste:
- Trees store energy in their branches and leaves. When these are removed, the tree must use its reserves to heal and grow back, which can deplete its vitality, potentially shortening its lifespan.

5. Aesthetic Damage:
- Topped trees lose their natural shape and become aesthetically unpleasing. They often end up with an unnatural, bushy appearance that doesn't blend well with the landscape.

6. Environmental Impact:
- Trees are vital for air quality and carbon sequestration. Topping reduces these benefits by stunting the tree's ability to provide oxygen and absorb CO2 effectively.

7. Economic Costs:
- Although topping might seem like a cost-saving measure, the long-term health issues and increased maintenance it causes can lead to greater expenses, including potential tree removal if the tree's health declines beyond recovery.

Why Arborists Refuse to Top Trees

- Ethical Practice: Professional arborists adhere to industry standards that aim to promote tree health, safety, and beauty. Topping contradicts these principles.

- Certification and Standards: Organizations like the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) and local arboricultural associations discourage topping, educating professionals on better practices like crown reduction or thinning.

- Long-term Vision: Arborists look at the long-term health and functionality of trees within landscapes. Topping is a short-term solution with long-term negative consequences.

- Client Education: We at Apex Tree Service take pride in informing our clients about sustainable tree care practices, ensuring they understand why certain methods are detrimental.

What to Do Instead:

If you're concerned about the size or safety of your trees, consider alternatives:

- Crown Thinning: Removing selected branches to increase light penetration and air movement through the crown.
- Crown Raising: Removing lower branches to clear space for buildings, vehicles, or pedestrians.
- Crown Reduction: Carefully reducing the height or spread of a tree while maintaining its natural shape.

‍

Remember- 400 Million years of evolution is not wrong. If you are thinking about topping a tree you are wrong.

‍

At Apex Tree Service, we're committed to providing tree care that benefits both the tree and the property. If you've been considering tree topping or have trees that have been topped in the past, let's talk about how we can help restore their health and beauty. Contact us for a consultation where we can discuss the best practices for your landscape's trees. Remember, a healthy tree is a safe and beautiful tree.

‍